The Cost of Overconfidence: A case for humility in healthcare
Remember your first doctor show? ER's chaotic energy? House's arrogant brilliance? Grey's Anatomy's dramatic saves? Be honest, a little part of you probably got hooked, especially if you're a med SLP now. But here's the uncomfortable truth: These shows might be subtly poisoning our practice.
Think about it. How often do TV doctors actually say, "Hmm, I'm not entirely sure," or "There are significant risks to this approach. Let’s weigh the pros and cons before we move forward"? Rarely, right? They're the ultimate fixers, pulling tracheostomies out of thin air with pocketknives and straws (yes, ER, we're looking at you.). It's wildly entertaining, but it sets a dangerous expectation: Medicine can conquer anything, and we have all the answers.
And that swagger? That "I've got this" vibe? At least a little bit of this has rubbed off of many healthcare professionals, including SLPs. Of course, we want to reassure our patients and project competence. "Don't worry, I'm in charge." But what happens when our real-world limitations bump up against that TV-fueled confidence?
Why Overconfidence Leads to Patient Despair (and Lawsuits)
Imagine you're starving. Three friends rave about this 5-star restaurant. You picture culinary perfection. A savory dream-like experience you’ll be raving about for months. Then you get... a decent burger. It's fine, but your expectations were sky-high. The experience ends up in disappointment and maybe a smaller tip.
Now, amplify that disappointment by a thousand. That's what happens in a hospital when our confident pronouncements don't match the often-messy reality of illness and recovery. We set an impossible standard, and when we fall short (as we inevitably will), the result isn't just a bad review; it's despair, lost trust, and potentially legal action.
Are We Selling False Hope?
As SLPs, we're not immune. We've mainlined those medical dramas too. So, how does our inner TV doctor affect how we talk about modified diets? Are we glossing over the very real risks of dehydration, malnutrition, and a drastically reduced quality of life? Are we clearly laying out those potential downsides, or are we just presenting the "benefits" with a confident flourish and a neatly tied bow?
Are we presenting the theory with unwavering confidence, while quietly ignoring the shaky evidence in the research? If you've ever done this, take a breath. You're not alone. I've been there. It's the TV doctor whispering in our ear.
The Prescription: Humility, Patience, Compassion
I've asked smart SLPs what truly makes someone good at what we do. And the answers weren't about knowing every research article, having unwavering confidence, or using the most innovative techniques. They boiled down to three powerful things:
Humility: The guts to say, "I don't know," and the wisdom to seek answers. Instead of fighting our limitations and vulnerability, embrace it and own it.
Patience: The willingness to sit with our patients, to truly listen, and to explain complex issues in a way they understand, even if it takes time. It’s a rushed sprint like we say on TV, real care is often a marathon. Being able to wait for the results and make adjustments along the way is where the real strength lies.
Compassion: Putting the patient's well-being and perspective above our own need to appear competent. It's about truly educating them on the pros and cons of every option, not just dictating what we think is "best."
Those charismatic, all-knowing doctors on screen? They rarely showed the messy, uncertain reality of medicine. We only saw the triumphant diagnoses and the miraculous recoveries. Real life is nuanced, filled with difficult choices and imperfect outcomes.
Confidence is easy to fake. It’s easy to simply act like we have all the answers when the questions are impossibly difficult to answer. But who does that truly serve? The far more challenging – and infinitely more rewarding – path is one paved with humility, patience, and genuine compassion. That's the kind of care I'd want for my own family, and it's the only kind of care our patients deserve.
Liked this? Subscribe below for more just like it.
